In the Matter of Manju Mahendra Joshi Vs. Lavasa Corporation ltd. Complaint no. AT006000000000096, decided on 17.04.2018 beforeThe Maharashtra Real Estate Appellate Tribunal
In the Matter of Manju Mahendra Joshi Vs. Lavasa Corporation ltd. Complaint no. AT006000000000096, decided on 17.04.2018 beforeThe Maharashtra Real Estate Appellate Tribunal ruled that “ Long term leases would amount to sale and hence lessees will also fall within the definition of allottee”
This Order was further upheld by the Order of Bombay high Court in Lavasa Corporation Limited v. Manju Narendra Joshi (C.A. No. 791 of 2018) decided on 07.08.2018.
On behalf of the lessor it was contended that since the impugned agreement was an 'agreement of lease' and not an ‘agreement for sale’, the provisions of RERA would not be applicable.
The definition of ‘promoter’ under section 2(zk) of RERA was relied upon by the lessor, as it contemplates a person, who constructs or caused to be constructed an apartment ‘for the purpose of selling’.
Reliance was also placed on the definition of 'allottee', under Section 2(d) of RERA, which specifically provides that allottee does not include a person to whom plot, apartment or building is ‘given on rent’.
Reliance was placed on the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of R.K. Palshikar (HUF) v. CIT, M.P., Nagpur and Bhandara, 1988 (172) ITR 311, wherein it was held that lease for a period of 99 (ninety nine) years would amount to transfer of capital assets. A judgment of the Madras High Court was also relied upon, which held that a lease for a period of 99 (ninety nine) years is an alienation as a sale, and mere use of the word 'lease' or the fact that a long term is fixed would not by itself make the document in lease.
The intention of RERA, as highlighted by the Supreme Court in the case of R.S. Raghunath v. State of Karnataka, (1992) 1 SCC 335 was also looked at, which was to protect the interest of consumers who have invested substantial amounts in real estate projects. If they are excluded from the definition of 'Allottee' and thereby from the protection given under the Act, by giving restrictive meaning to the term 'Allottee', the very object of RERA would stand frustrated.
